To become an extremist, you must care about finding the truth and doing the right thing. That's a radical statement, but nobody would put in the effort otherwise. They'd have to be eager for understanding to eat up those lies and just as eager to help to act on them. Lydia was born during a time when Sunday service was an obligation and your identity--your politics, your way of living, and the things you believed--were tied in with your chosen sect. Her beliefs were reinforced regularly over a period of decades. She'd give her all in praise and worship sessions, singing, clapping, closing her eyes with her hands raised in the air. The music would begin slowly at first, while the band began to wake the crowd up from their morning stupor. Then the tempo would increase, and they'd get into it, shouting, jumping up and down, crying out with joy. Soon the pace would slow again, and things would get serious. People would start the cry, and the lyrics would get more intense. There's a science to that type of performance. It's meant to work the congregation up then break them down, and get them ready for the message ahead. It is brainwashing, but it's not framed as such. It's how pastors are taught to reach their flock.
Eventually, the message would get more urgent, serenaded at first with piano music, then synthesizers, and eventually recorded tracks. It was meant to elicit a certain reaction, like sadness, or a revelation. Things would get political. They'd talk about the evils of moral decay, abortion, homosexuality, the fertility crisis, and global warming. They would announce that they wanted to change the country and bring it back to God. Services would get longer, and all sorts of volunteer opportunities and groups would spring up, meant to support what would become a very real revolution. It's easy to see how a woman of Lydia's age could be fooled by all of this, especially if they were raised in the church and told their entire lives that it was the source of all goodness and light. She would've eaten up every word, and she did. She wanted to get involved. She wanted to do the right thing, which gradually morphed into becoming an aunt, beating up a certain type of woman, and forcing them to take part in the ceremony. She was just like June, a frog in a boiling pot of water. She didn't see the danger or the corruption until it was too late.
When she did start to change, after June confronted her about the abuse against handmaids, it was hard to tell whether or not she was fully aware. But Ann Dowd, the actress who plays her, recently talked about it in an interview. She said that Lydia was very perceptive. She knew Putnam was killed for political reasons. She saw everything the commanders had been doing, including the corruption, what she'd consider blasphemy, and their lies. She didn't like any of it. She might not have been aware at first that she was a glorified madame, but you can bet she'll do something to remedy that.
Lydia's Future: Lydia doesn't like having the eyes at the red center without her permission. She will probably have them banned when she threatens Lawrence into releasing Janine. The new spin-off, 'The Testaments,' will air after the series finale, and it will center around Lydia's actions 15 years in the future. This article will not reveal her secrets, but know that she is cunning and capable--a rare type of human that we only see once in a generation. There is nothing she can't do if she puts her mind to it, and she will.