Jacobson and Graham incorporated both old and new faces in the adaptation, such as Chanté Adams of A Journal for Jordan as Max, Gbemisola Ikumelo of Sex Education as Clance, D’Arcy Carden of Barry as Greta, Nick Offerman of Pam & Tommy as Dove, Roberta Colindrez of Vida as Lupe, Alex Désert of Swingers as Edgar, Saida A. Ekulona of Better Call Saul as Toni, Priscilla Delgado of Julieta as Esti, and Kate Berlant of Search Party as Shirley.
Other characters include Don Fanelli of Broad City as Alan, Lil Frex as Ana, Nat Faxon of Gaslit as Marshall, Rae Gray as Terri, Dale Dickey of Claws as Beverly, Melanie Field of You as Jo, Molly Ephraim of Last Man Standing as Maybelle and Aaron Jennings of Insecure as Guy. Jacobson also portrayed himself as Carson.