While the first season had a cast list comprising stars like Sydney Sweeney, Alexandra Daddario, and Murray Barlett, the new season introduces an entirely different cast. This is largely unsurprising, as the season involves a different story at a location miles away from season 1's location, and the show is still classified as a limited/anthology series.
The audience should expect actors like Michael Imperioli, the stunning Aubrey Plaza and Will Sharpe. Plaza will play Harper Spiller, the main character of the series this time. While Sharpe will play Harper Spiller’s husband, Ethan Spiller. So far, only two returning casts from the first season have been confirmed. They are Jennifer Coolidge (who played Tanya Mcquiod in the first season) and Jon Gries (who played Greg). Tanya and Greg are expected to continue their steaming romance into this new season. In a Variety interview, Aubrey Plaza expressed that she was a big fan of Mark White and thoroughly enjoyed working with him.